Top 5 Best Shampoo Bars of 2024
After testing five of the best shampoo bars available, one product completely transformed my routine. If you’re looking for an effortless way to bring back your hair’s vibrancy without adding time to your day, keep reading to discover which shampoo bar delivered the best results!
For years, I struggled with thin, brittle hair that had started graying before I was ready.
I’d tried everything from hair dyes to thickening sprays, even specialty shampoos that promised to make my hair look fuller and more youthful.
Nothing worked for long.
All I wanted was a simple, fuss-free solution that would help me regain my natural color and strengthen my hair without adding extra steps to my day.
That’s when a friend at the hair salon told me about shampoo bars.
She swore by them and mentioned a few, especially those designed for hair growth and color restoration.
I’d never considered a shampoo bar before, but with her recommendation, I figured it was worth a try.
Stick with me to read the full review and see why Earth Toner earned the top spot on my list, becoming my go-to choice for natural color restoration and healthy hair growth.
July - Chief Product Researcher at BestConsumerPicks.org
With a relentless passion for uncovering the best of the best, July leaves no stone unturned in her quest for excellence. Armed with a magnifying glass and a zest for adventure, she meticulously analyzes product specifications, conducts in-depth research, and tests products firsthand to ensure our recommendations are accurate and reliable.
Best Overall
Overall Grade
A+
Rating
9.8/10
OVERALL ANALYSIS
Pros
- Guided Cooking Perfection
- Darkens hair naturally
- Promotes hair growth
- Nourishes and repairs
- Organic
- Home-made
- Non-greasy
- Non-toxic and chemical-free
- Safe for daily use
- Suitable for all hair types
- Compact and travel-friendly
- Cruelty free
Cons
- Limited Stock, Frequently Sells Out
- Only Available in US/Canada
WRAP-UP
- Ingredients & Features: This shampoo bar is crafted with a unique blend of herbal extracts and natural ingredients designed to darken hair and support growth. By stimulating the pigments within hair follicles, it gradually restores natural color without the need for dyes, while nourishing and strengthening each strand.
- Durability and Convenience: The shampoo bar’s compact size makes it perfect for travel, and its non-toxic, chemical-free formula is safe for daily use. Unlike traditional liquid shampoos, it’s easy to use, long-lasting, and doesn’t disrupt your daily routine.
- Verdict: If you’re seeking a hassle-free way to regain your hair’s natural color and support growth, this shampoo bar is the top choice. It’s easy to use, effective, and natural, making it a must-have for anyone looking to enhance their hair’s vibrancy and strength.
Best for Men
Overall Grade
A
Rating
9.6/10
OVERALL ANALYSIS
Pros
- Restores hair color naturally & effectively
- Engages the “color” cells deep within the roots of your hair
- Perfect for Hair, Beard, Eyebrows
- Science-backed shampoo
- No mess, no hassle
- Fights Hair Loss
- Natural Ingredients
- Safe for all hair types
Cons
- Limited Color Option
- Only available online
WRAP-UP
Gray Away focuses on the natural causes of gray hair and stops them in their tracks. Gray Away says they use a “science-backed formula that stimulates melanocytes, the cells which determine color vibrancy in follicles, to return individual hair strands to their original color.” We learned about Gray Away when they offered a 50% discount when they first launched. Since then, they’ve sold out of the product every other week. The best part? It works on your head, beard, and even eyebrows. This is a must-buy!
By far, Gray Away is the most effective shampoo for reversing gray hair.
3. Kitsch Shampoo Bar
Best Alternative
Overall Grade
B+
Rating
8.9/10
OVERALL ANALYSIS
Pros
- Strengthens & thickens hair
- Paraben sulfate & cruelty Free
- Vegan
- Affordable
Cons
- Leaves greasy residue
- Doesn’t work as advertised
- Increased acne & hair shed
WRAP-UP
- Precision and Features: The Kitsch Shampoo Bar is marketed as a vegan, sulfate-free option that aims to strengthen and thicken hair. However, users report issues with greasy residue and increased acne, which limits its effectiveness for daily use and may not meet its advertised benefits.
- Durability and Convenience: While affordable and eco-friendly, Kitsch can leave a heavy residue on hair, which detracts from its ease of use. Many users find the buildup inconvenient, making it less suitable for long-term, daily use compared to more lightweight alternatives like Earth Toner.
- Verdict: Kitsch is a budget-friendly choice, but for a truly effective, non-greasy option that promotes hair growth and natural color restoration, Earth Toner is the better choice for consistent, quality results.
4. Hair Thickness Maximizer Shampoo Bar
from Hair Thickness Maximizer
Overall Grade
B
Rating
7.8/10
OVERALL ANALYSIS
Pros
- Promotes hair growth
- Hair color safe
- PH balanced
Cons
- Makes hair limp
- Not for all hair types
- Contains alcohol
WRAP-UP
- Precision and Features: This shampoo bar claims to promote hair growth and is pH-balanced, making it safe for color-treated hair. However, it tends to make hair limp and contains alcohol, which may not suit all hair types, especially those needing volume.
- Durability and Convenience: While it’s portable and safe for color-treated hair, the limpness it causes and its alcohol content may not suit users with sensitive or fine hair seeking volume and bounce.
- Verdict: Hair Thickness Maximizer is a decent option for those with color-treated hair, but for a more volumizing, versatile solution that effectively promotes hair growth and natural color restoration, Earth Toner is the superior choice.
5. The Earthling Co. Shampoo Bar
from The Earthling Co
Overall Grade
C+
Rating
7.5/10
OVERALL ANALYSIS
Pros
- Paraben & sulfate free
- Natural & Vegan
- Helps with hair regrowth
Cons
- Reports of increased hair shedding
- Makes hair limp
- Not for all hair types as advertised
WRAP-UP
- Precision and Features: The Earthling Co. Shampoo Bar is crafted with natural, vegan ingredients aimed at supporting hair regrowth. However, some users report increased hair shedding and limpness, with mixed results across different hair types.
- Durability and Convenience: While eco-friendly and free from parabens and sulfates, its inconsistent results and reports of hair shedding make it less ideal for those seeking reliable, daily hair growth support.
- Verdict: The Earthling Co. Shampoo Bar is an eco-conscious choice, but for consistent results across all hair types with the added benefit of natural color restoration, Earth Toner remains the top pick for dependable quality and performance.
Among All the Shampoo Bars I Tried, Earth Toner Was the Clear Winner—Here’s Why
I’ve spent years trying different solutions for my thinning, graying hair, but most products left me disappointed.
I wanted my hair to look fuller and more vibrant without harsh dyes or a complicated routine.
That’s when I started hearing about shampoo bars that could help with hair growth and color restoration, and my friend at the salon recommended Earth Toner.
My First Experience with Earth Toner
When I first tried Earth Toner, I loved how easy it was to use.
It didn’t add any extra steps to my routine…
I simply used it as I would a regular shampoo…
And my hair felt soft and clean.
After a few washes, I began to notice a change.
My hair started looking darker and healthier, and the thin areas felt stronger.
I loved that it didn’t feel like I was using a “treatment” or dye.
I just lathered up, rinsed, and went about my day.
The Earth Toner Shampoo Bar was exactly what I was looking for…no mess, no fuss.
Did Earth Toner Live Up to the Hype?
Absolutely, yes.
I’ll admit I was skeptical at first, especially after trying so many products that didn’t work.
But Earth Toner really surprised me.
With every wash, my hair felt softer, thicker, and looked naturally darker.
It didn’t coat my hair or feel greasy, and I loved knowing it was free of harsh chemicals and was cruelty-free.
After just three weeks, I saw a huge difference in my hair’s texture, color, and fullness.
Why You Should Try Earth Toner if You Want Fuller, Darker Hair
For anyone dealing with graying or thinning hair, Earth Toner is an easy, effective solution.
It fits right into your daily routine without any fuss, bringing back your hair’s natural color while promoting growth and strength.
And with a 60% discount, there’s no better time to try it. Plus, with a 30-day money-back guarantee, you can test it out risk-free.
Why Earth Toner Stands Out as the Best Shampoo Bar for Hair Growth
After testing multiple options, Earth Toner is hands-down my favorite for these key reasons:
Darkens Hair Naturally
Earth Toner restores natural color by stimulating pigments within the hair follicles, bringing back your original shade without chemical dyes.
Promotes Hair Growth
Its herbal formula encourages blood flow to the scalp, helping to reduce hair loss and promote thicker, healthier growth.
Nourishes and Moisturizes
Packed with natural ingredients, Earth Toner moisturizes and strengthens hair, making it soft, shiny, and manageable.
Non-Toxic and Safe for Daily Use
This shampoo bar is gentle on hair and scalp, free from toxic chemicals, and safe for daily use.
Compact and Travel-Friendly
Earth Toner’s small, convenient design makes it easy to use anywhere—whether you’re at home, the gym, or traveling.
FAQs From My Experience with Earth Toner
After using the Earth Toner shampoo bar for a few weeks, friends started asking me tons of questions, so I’ve pulled together the most frequent ones to help you out:
Does it really work to darken hair?
Yes! I saw noticeable darkening after a few weeks of daily use, and my natural color started returning without any harsh dyes.
Is it easy to use?
Super easy. I just lathered it up like a regular shampoo, so it didn’t add any extra steps to my routine.
How long does a bar last?
Each bar lasts for up to 60 washes, depending on how often you use it and how much lather you create. I’ve been using mine for two months, and there’s still plenty left.
Is it safe for color-treated hair?
Yes, Earth Toner is safe and gentle for all hair types, even color-treated hair.
Does it help with hair growth?
Definitely. My hair feels thicker and looks fuller, and I’ve noticed less hair loss since I started using it.
July - Chief Product Researcher
Armed with a meticulous eye for detail and a dedication to unbiased reviews, July leads our team in uncovering the best products on the market. Her expertise and rigorous testing ensure you get the information you need to make informed purchasing decisions.
Tired of sifting through endless reviews and conflicting information? We’ve been there. At BestConsumerPicks.org, we’re dedicated to helping you make informed decisions about the products that matter most.
Get In Touch
- Email: customer@bestconsumerpicks.org
- Hours: Mon-Fri 9:00AM - 5:00PM
Pages
© 2025 All Rights Reserved.